Is the criminal justice system blind to race and ethnicity?: The case of fatal work accidents in the construction industry
Is the criminal justice system blind to race and ethnicity
Despite growing media and public interest in recent years in the issue of fatal work accidents in the construction industry, there in fact has been an upswing in the number of fatalities. The construction industry is a dangerous industry for workers, and about half of the fatal work accidents in Israel take place there. This study was designed to examine how the law enforcement system handles cases of fatal work accidents, where most of the workers are foreign workers. The article examines whether there is a difference in the criminal procedures between work accidents and road accidents, which are not identified with a particular demographic sector. The study findings showed that there is a significant link between the type of fatal accident and the identity of the victim, and the decisions made during the criminal proceedings for a fatal work accident as compared to a fatal road accident. The findings partially correspond with the assumptions of the Marxist structural school of victimology, which sees a relationship between the victim's social status and the way the criminal justice system handles the case. Although based on a relatively small sample, these findings indicate that there is a need to substantially strengthen and regulate the investigative and criminal aspects of the treatment of fatal work accidents in the construction industry.
Cohen, R., Ra'anan, N. and Gittelson, N. (2016). Report on Work Accidents in Israel: Status for 2011-2015. Retrieved from the Ministry of Labor, Welfare and Social Services: https://employment.molsa.gov.il/Employment/SafetyAndHealth/ResearchAndProjects/Reports/Reports/AccidentReport2011-2015.pdf (In Hebrew).
Danieli, A. (2018, May 30). Since the beginning of the year: a 30% jump in the number of fatalities of construction workers. Calcalist. Retrieved from: https://www.calcalist.co.il/real_estate/articles/0,7340,L-3739196,00.html (In Hebrew).
Elbashan, Y. (2005). Strangers in the Realm of the Law: Access to Justice in Israel. Bnei-Brak: Hakibutz Hameuchad (In Hebrew).
Elias, R. (1986). The politics of victimization, victims, victimology and human rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Falandysz, L. (1982). Victimology in radical perspective. In H.J. Schneider (Ed.) The victim in international perspective (pp. 105-114). Berlin: de Gruyter.
Feldman, Y. (2008). Who the hell is this victim? The rise and fall of Abraham, the fetter in the 1950s. Mickan, 9, 125- 157. (In Hebrew).
Foucault, M. (2015). The Punitive Society: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1972-1973. Davidson, A. I. (Ed.). London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Gittelson, N., Cohen, R., & Ra'anan, N. (2015). Report on Work Accidents in Israel: Status Report 2010 - 2014. Ministry of Labor, Welfare and Social Services. Retrieved from https://employment.molsa.gov.il/Employment/SafetyAndHealth/ResearchAndProjects/Reports/Reports/AccidentReport2010-2014.pdf (In Hebrew).
Gittelson, N., Cohen, R., & Ra'anan, N. (2016, June). Work accidents in Israel: 2011 - 2015. Periodical surveys 278. National Insurance Institute. Retrieved from: https://www.btl.gov.il/Publications/survey/Documents/seker_278.pdf (In Hebrew).
Hacker, D. (2008). An invitation to the sociology of law and an initial mapping of the scope in Israel. Din Udvarim - Haifa Law Review, 4, 95-129. (In Hebrew).
Hagan, J., Silva E. T., & Simpson, J. H. (1977). Conflict and consensus in the designation of deviance. Social Forces, 56(2), 320-340.
Haney, C. (1991). The Fourteenth Amendment and symbolic legality. Let them eat due process. Law & Human Behavior, 15(2), 183-216.
Israel Police (2014, February 1). Grounds and considerations for closing criminal cases. Procedure of Investigations Division no. 300.01.152 Retrieved from the Israeli Police website: https://www.police.gov.il/menifa/05.300.01.152_1.pdf (In Hebrew).
Kirchhoff, G. F. (1990). Victimology, human rights and criminal procedure. Paper presented in the workshop: Human rights of the victim and criminal justice. International society of criminology, Miskolc, Hungary.
Kirshenbaum, A. (2009). Victimology and Jewish Law: Focusing on the Victim and the Offended. Law and Business, 10, 147-182. Retrieved from: http://portal.idc.ac.il/he/lawreview/volumes/volume10/documents/kirshnbaum.pdf (In Hebrew).
Knesset, Labor, Welfare and Health Committee (2018, February 5). Protocol No. 700. Retrieved from the Knesset website: https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Ffs.knesset.gov.il%2F%2F20%2FCommittees%2F20_ptv_488863.doc (In Hebrew).
Landau, S. (2003). The Social Perception of Victims: Outlines for the Definition of the Dimensions of Victimology. In M. Hovav, L.Sebba, & M. Amir, (Eds.) Trends in Criminology: Theory, Policy and Practice (pp: 797-809). Jerusalem: The Harry and Michael Sacher Institute for Legislative Research and Comparative Law, the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (In Hebrew).
Larnau, H. (2016). Crime and Law Enforcement - Theory, Policy, Criticism. Haifa: Pardes Publishing. (In Hebrew).
Marx, K. and Engels, P. (1975). The Communist Manifesto. Chicago: Kerr, 1982.
Matthews, R. A. (2014). Marxist criminology. In M. Schwartz & S. Hatty (Eds.), Controversies in critical criminology. (pp. 1-14). Cincinnati: Oh:Tylor & Francis.
Mendelsohn, B. (1963). The Origin of the Doctrine of Victimology. Experta Criminologica ,3, 239-44.
Mills, S. (2003). Michel Foucault. London and New York: Routledge.
Nathan, G. (2011, December 13). Non-Israelis in Israel (Foreigners, Foreign Workers, Refugees, Infiltrators and Asylum Seekers), 2010-2011. Retrieved from the Knesset website: http://www.knesset.gov.il/mmm/data/pdf/m02986.pdf (In Hebrew).
Public Committee for the Advancement of Occupational Safety and Health in the State of Israel (Adam Committee) (2014, March). Report and recommendations. Retrieved from: http://graphics-lapam.org.il/clients/calcala/vadat_adam_2/vaadat_adam.html (In Hebrew).
Ra'anan, N. (2018). Report on work accident in Israel - the first median for 2017. Retrieved from the Ministry of Labor, Welfare and Social Services website: https://employment.molsa.gov.il/Employment/SafetyAndHealth/ResearchAndProjects/Reports/Reports/AccidentReport_S1-2017.pdf . (In Hebrew).
Ra'anan, N., Cohen, R., Gittelson, N., & Berna, A. (2017). Report on Work Accidents and Occupational Illness: Status Report 2012 - 2016. Retrieved from the Ministry of Labor, Welfare and Social Services website: https://employment.molsa.gov.il/Employment/SafetyAndHealth/ResearchAndProjects/Reports/Reports/AccidentReport2012-2016.pdf (In Hebrew).
Rattner, A., & Fishman, G. (2004). Justice for all? Jews and Arabs in the Israeli legal system. In: E. Levy, A. Shadmi, & Y. Kim (Eds.). Seeking Justice - Studies in Crime and Law Enforcement in Israel (pp. 110-185). Tel Aviv: Cherikover Beit Berl. (In Hebrew).
Shoham, E. (2009). Undocumented foreign workers detained in the Israeli prison system. In M. Shechory, S. Ben David, & D. Soen (Eds). Work immigrants and social problems: An international perspective (pp.189-205). New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Shoham, E. (2011). The back yard of the detention system in Israel: foreign workers without a permit. Israeli criminology, 1, 29-53. (In Hebrew).
Shoham, E.. & Abulafia, J. (2010). Judicial decisions on violent offenses between spouses in the Magistrate's Court. Megamot, 47, 103-129. (In Hebrew).
Shoham, E. Doron, S. (eds.) (2016). Between visibility and transparency - the attitude toward "the other" in Israeli society. Ashkelon: Ashkelon Academic College. (In Hebrew).
Shoham, G. S., & Hoffman, J. (1991). A primer in the sociology of crime. N.Y.: Harrow and Heston, publisher.
Simpson, S. S. (1989). Feminist theory, crime and justice. Criminology, 27, 605-631.
Taylor, I., Walton, P., & Young, J. (1975) Critical Criminology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
The State Comptroller (2016). Ministry of Economy and Industry - Workers' safety and health. Annual Report 66c. Retrieved from the State Comptroller's website: http://www.mevaker.gov.il/he/Reports/Report_537/1986e269-7871-4a40-a1a5-e639fca550f6/222-safety.pdf (In Hebrew).
The state prosecutor (2018, January 14). Directive 1.3 - Closing of cases on grounds of "lack of evidence" and grounds for "lack of guilt". Retrieved from the Ministry of Justice website: http://www.justice.gov.il/Units/StateAttorney/Guidelines/001.3.pdf (In Hebrew).
Yaron, L. (2017, November 23). Ardan and Katz refuse to budget a unit for the investigation of constuction accidents, and its establishment is postponed to 2019. Haaretz. Retrieved from: https://www.haaretz.co.il/news/education/.premium-1.4624686?=&ts=_1515357900148 (In Hebrew).
Zeira, G. (2015, December 14). Work accidents in the construction industry. Retrieved from the Knesset, Research and Information: https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/59e62efd-6493-e511-80d6-00155d0204d4/2_59e62efd-6493-e511-80d6-00155d0204d4_11_7970.pdf (In Hebrew).
Zeira, G. (2016, February 8). Data on fatalities in work accidents in the construction industry in 2010-2015. Retrieved from the Knesset, Research and Information: Center: https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/b111c97c-79ce-e511-80d0-00155d0acb9e/2_b111c97c-79ce-e511-80d0-00155d0acb9e_11_9205.pdf (In Hebrew).
Zeira, G. (2016, September 26). Data on investigation procedures and legal proceedings following work accidents in the construction industry: update document. Retrieved from the Knesset, Research and Information Center: https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/904b780b-cfde-e511-80d6-00155d0204d4/2_904b780b-cfde-e511-80d6-00155d0204d4_11_10434.pdf (In Hebrew).
Zeira, G. (2017, December 27). Data on the files of the State Attorney's Office that were filed between 2010 and February 2016 on suspicion of negligent offenses in cases of work accidents in the construction industry. Retrieved from the Knesset, Research and Information Center: https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/55c5c241-8fe8-e711-80de-00155d0a0235/2_55c5c241-8fe8-e711-80de-00155d0a0235_11_7923.pdf (In Hebrew).
Zisser, B. (1999). About left and right: a window for modern ideological discourse. Tel Aviv: Schocken Books. (In Hebrew).
Copyright (c) 2019 efrat shoham, Eitan Nictora
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The author warrants that the article is original, written by stated author(s), has not been published before, contains no unlawful statements, does not infringe the rights of others, is subject to copyright that is vested exclusively in the author and free of any third party rights, and that any necessary written permissions to quote from other sources have been obtained by the author(s).